Justice secretary explains prison gender policy
Newly convicted or remanded transgender prison inmates will initially be placed in jails according to their gender at birth, the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) has confirmed.
The policy used to be confirmed in an pressing evaluate which came upon a double rapist being placed in a girls’s reformatory didn’t attach female prisoners in risk of hurt.
Nonetheless, the SPS mentioned it received “conflicting” dinky print on Isla Bryson.
It also referred to as for an pressing evaluate of admission suggestions for some inmates.
The investigation used to be ordered by Justice Secretary Keith Brown in the wake of public outcry after Bryson used to be initially housed in segregation at Cornton Vale prison in Stirling.
Image source, PA Media
Isla Bryson, a convicted rapist, used to be moved from Cornton Vale to a male wing at HMP Edinburgh
Bryson – who will be sentenced later this month for raping two girls whereas she is known as a person referred to as Adam Graham – used to be then moved to a male wing at HMP Edinburgh.
In an interview with BBC Scotland, Mr Brown initially mentioned the rule applied only to transgender individuals convicted of violence against girls.
Nonetheless after an intervention from a member of his team, the justice secretary clarified that each one transgender prisoners will inch into an evaluate in a prison provider facility which suits the gender of their birth.
He added: “That will very in general be a direction of which is undertaken in a segregated environment, before an evaluate is made as to the attach apart the person goes.
“And if it appears the person has that history [of violence against women or girls] then definitely they won’t be going to, in the event that they are a trans woman, to the female estate.”
SPS chief govt Teresa Medhurst mentioned in a letter to Mr Brown that used to be printed alongside a summary of the Bryson case evaluate that she had ordered an pressing evaluate of all transgender girls in Scottish prisons.
She mentioned: “Till these stories are full, any transgender person currently in custody and who has any history of violence against girls – including sexual offences – won’t be relocated from the male to the female estate.
“In addition, any newly convicted or remanded transgender prisoner will initially be placed in an institution commensurate with their birth gender.”
Beneath steering drawn up in 2014, the prison provider says “accommodation offered must be the one that best suits the person in custody’s wants and could perchance additionally fair contemplate the gender in which the person in custody is currently living.”
Nonetheless an updated SPS policy from final month mentioned that no newly convicted or remanded transgender prisoner with a history of violence against girls would be housed in female prison facilities.
The latest change come that transgender girls will now automatically inch to a male prison without reference to whether or no longer or no longer they contain got outdated convictions of violence against girls. They’re going to then be assessed before a decision is taken on the attach apart to situation them longer-length of time.
Nonetheless, the evaluate says that in “exceptional conditions” a transgender person with a history of violence against girls could perchance doubtlessly be relocated to or placed in a prison which does no longer match their gender at birth, with ministerial approval.
Image source, PA Media
A articulate against transgender girls being housed in female prisons used to be held outdoors the Scottish Parliament on Thursday
The SPS evaluate made four key recommendations to the Scottish government.
It came upon the prison provider received “conflicting and exiguous information” about Bryson beyond the instant convictions and mentioned a “shared justice direction of” for the admission of transgender individuals to prisons ought to be considered.
The SPS also referred to as for an pressing evaluate of admission suggestions and improved communications about transgender prisoners from other justice sector organisations.
The file concluded SPS policy used to be followed in Bryson’s case and mentioned an individualised come to risk assessments ought to continue.
“It’s beneficial that this person centred, individualised come, which seeks to balance the rights of the individual with the dangers they pose to themselves and to others continues and is encouraged,” the file mentioned.
Key findings and recommendations resulting from the evaluate had been printed on Thursday, but Ms Medhurst mentioned she believed it used to be “no longer obligatory” to submit the stout file due to the extent of personal information it contains.
Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross entreated the first minister to submit in stout the evaluate of the Bryson case at First Minister’s Questions earlier on Thursday, with Ms Sturgeon pledging only to free up the main findings.
Bryson used to be came upon responsible of raping two girls in 2016 and 2019 in Clydebank and Glasgow before she changed gender.
The evaluate into the handling of that case by the prison provider used to be carried out by the Scottish Prison Service final Friday, with a summary being made public on Thursday afternoon.
The SPS has also been conducting a Gender Identity and Gender Reassignment (GIGR) policy evaluate since 2019 in response to concerns raised about welfare of individuals in its care.
Mr Brown confirmed the new policy on assessing transgender prisoners would remain in situation pending the findings of the GIGR evaluate.
In response to the Bryson file, he mentioned: “All recommendations from the evaluate contain been well-liked by Ms Medhurst as chief govt and can be improved by SPS in collaboration with others as wanted.
“As confirmed in the letter, SPS will factor the learning identified from this evaluate into its GIGR policy evaluate, which is ongoing.”
At the heart of this case are two abominable crimes and two girls who had been raped.
At points in the frenzy surrounding Isla Bryson these info contain been drowned out and so it is fee pausing to contemplate what this fiasco must be like for the victims.
It’s some distance in general a case which is having an impression on other girls who’re survivors of sexual violence and on trans individuals who feel unfairly stigmatised by about a of the coverage.
That having been mentioned, the handling of the Isla Bryson case has also been a astronomical headache for the Scottish government.
First Nicola Sturgeon stumbled when answering questions about what the case come for the principle of gender self-identification, which she has championed.
Then the Scottish Executive used to be compelled to clarify a misleading information free up and the Justice Secretary struggled to explain exactly what the SPS used to be doing.
All of here’s producing criticism from the SNP’s opponents as you want to quiz but it undoubtedly is also generating frustration for lots of supporters of independence, alarmed that the rolling rows are damaging their reason.
